Federal enforcement has narrowed the pipeline of new truck drivers, and the largest truckload carriers spent their third-quarter earnings calls explaining how they plan to compete for the ones who remain. Their answer leans on safety records, home time and in-house training at least as much as on pay.
Key Takeaways
For years the standard response to a driver shortage was a bigger sign-on bonus and a few more cents per mile. The third-quarter earnings season suggests the largest truckload carriers no longer think that is enough. Executives at J.B. Hunt, Werner, Knight-Swift and Schneider all described targeted spending to recruit and keep drivers, and Trucking Dive's review of those calls found a common thread: carriers are raising wages as stricter federal enforcement constrains the driver pipeline, but they are selling safety and dependability as the real differentiator. "You just don't solve this by money alone," Schneider president and CEO Jim Filter told analysts.
The supply of new drivers is being squeezed from several directions at once, and most of the pressure is regulatory. In February, FMCSA issued a final rule on non-domiciled commercial driver's licenses that took effect in mid-March. Only holders of H-2A, H-2B or E-2 visas now qualify, employment authorization documents are no longer accepted, and states cannot issue a non-domiciled CDL for longer than one year. FMCSA said 17 crashes and 30 deaths in 2025 involved non-domiciled drivers who would not be eligible under the new rules.
Training capacity has shrunk too. The same month, DOT proposed removing more than 550 CDL schools from the national training registry after more than 1,400 onsite investigations over five days, with another 97 schools still under investigation. The Commercial Vehicle Training Association said the "surprise enforcement blitz caused many CDL mills to exit the industry altogether." Both moves target drivers whose qualifications could not be verified, which is the point. The side effect is fewer new entrants overall.
Werner put a number on it. CEO Derek Leathers said enrollment at the company's own driver training program and at other schools has fallen between 20% and 30%, according to Trucking Dive's coverage of Werner's results. "That's an ongoing battle to get people kind of interested in professional driving as an occupation," he said. Werner said it had made "the deliberate decision to accelerate investments in driver recruiting and onboarding," and TD Cowen wrote that the company's comments speak to "the acute pressure carriers are facing."
Wages are moving. In September, Anderson Trucking Service raised van driver pay from 60 cents to 70 cents per mile, a 16.7% increase that can reach 72 cents with years of service. But the larger carriers described pay as one lever among several, and an expensive one. J.B. Hunt CFO Brad Delco said driver-related investments, volatile fuel prices and higher claims and medical costs together reduced third-quarter operating income by more than $50 million compared with the second quarter, and group medical costs alone accounted for more than $16 million of that. "We will control what we can through safety, productivity, asset utilization and disciplined execution," he said.
Schneider is tying pay increases to rate recovery and targeting them where returns justify the spend. "We're not just throwing money at everything," Filter said. For shippers, that matters: carriers that cannot pass costs through are choosing which lanes and which drivers to invest in, rather than lifting pay across the board.
When the pool of new drivers shrinks, the carriers that keep the ones they have are the ones that can still grow, and that is now a safety and operations question as much as a pay question. Logistics Focus analysis
The carriers' own framing is telling. Leathers highlighted a 20-year low in DOT preventable accidents per mile in the third quarter, and tied driver quality directly to cost. "We've got to bend the curve on the insurance line and the only way to do it is with high-quality drivers," he said. He also pointed to schedule: more than 70% of Werner's fleet gets home multiple times a week, a result of its dedicated concentration and engineered routes. "It's about making the job increasingly attractive," he said.
Knight-Swift CEO Adam Miller described the company's "large academy network and driver training program" as a way to source and develop its own drivers rather than compete for a shrinking pool of experienced ones. "I think we're in a better space as an industry because we have safer drivers on the road," he said. The common logic across all four calls is that a safer, better-trained driver costs less to insure, stays longer and keeps a truck moving, so the investment pays back in claims and turnover as well as in capacity.
Driver wellbeing is the next piece carriers are trying to measure. The American Transportation Research Institute is surveying drivers and carriers on driver health and medical costs, including whether carriers offer wellness programs and how medical costs are split, and has extended the survey through December 4. With J.B. Hunt citing a $16 million medical cost increase in a single quarter, that data will land on budgets that are already under strain.
The enforcement that is shrinking the driver pool is unlikely to reverse, and most of it is aimed at exactly the drivers carriers say they do not want. That leaves the industry competing harder for a smaller number of qualified people. The carriers describing the strongest position are the ones that can show those people a safe operation, a predictable schedule and a path to train in-house. Pay still matters, but on the evidence of this earnings season, it is no longer the whole offer.

Guide
Werner ties lower insurance costs to high-quality drivers and a record low in preventable accidents. Lytx's upgrade guide covers the coaching and driver engagement changes that move a plateaued safety program toward results like that.
Download
Guide
Carriers are now selling their safety record to the drivers they want to hire. IntelliShift explains how fleets build a culture where drivers, dispatchers and managers share responsibility for risk, which is what a candidate actually experiences.
Download
Guide
With fewer new drivers coming through the schools, Werner is accelerating its spend on onboarding as well as recruiting. DoorDash's guide sets out practical ways to make new hires feel welcome, informed and ready to contribute from their first day.
Download
Fleets with strong safety records are renewing flat or near 5%, while weaker accounts face increases of 30% to 40%. With commercial auto still losing money, underwriters now price on documented evidence, not on the story a fleet tells.
86% of carriers recognize a driver is at risk less than 30 days before departure or only at resignation, and none spot it more than 60 days out. With 58.1% of drivers job hunting, retention has become an early-warning problem.